What this topic covers
Ethical issues in origination: loan originator compensation, kickbacks and referrals, redlining, steering and predatory practices, appraiser independence, fraud red flags and suspicious activity reports, advertising and UDAAP. These are original practice notes, not NMLS or CSBS documents, based on the federal laws and regulations in effect on January 1, 2027.
Compensation
- Percentage of the loan: a fixed percentage of the amount of credit is not a term or a proxy for a term, and may have a minimum or maximum dollar amount (12 CFR 1026.36(d)(1)(ii)); tiered percentages are not allowed (comment 36(d)(1)-9 to Regulation Z).
- Dual compensation: if any loan originator is paid directly by the consumer, no one else may pay it for that transaction (12 CFR 1026.36(d)(2)(i)(A)).
Kickbacks and referrals
- Thing of value: monies, discounts, salaries, commissions, fees, and trips or services at special or free rates; no dollar threshold (12 CFR 1024.14(d)).
- Permitted: payments to an attorney for services rendered, to one's own employees, to a lender's agent for services performed (12 CFR 1024.14(g)(1)), and normal promotional activities not conditioned on referrals (12 CFR 1024.14(g)(1)(vi)).
- Brokers: the cooperative brokerage exemption does not cover fees between real estate brokers and mortgage brokers (12 CFR 1024.14(g)(1)(v)).
Fair dealing
- Redlining: discrimination tied to who lives in a neighborhood, such as race or national origin; credit-score pricing and DTI limits apply to each applicant.
- Steering: directing a consumer to a loan for greater compensation, unless it is in the consumer's interest (12 CFR 1026.36(e)(1)).
- Predatory practices: flipping (repeated refinancing with new fees and no benefit), packing (unneeded products), equity stripping (lending on equity, not ability to repay), bait and switch.
- Appraiser independence: no causing or attempting to cause a value not based on the appraiser's independent judgment (12 CFR 1026.42(c)(1)).
Fraud red flags and SARs
- Red flags: a seller who is not the owner of record, payments outside closing, a large unexplained deposit, a quick resale at a much higher price without renovations. Payroll deposits matching pay stubs are not a red flag.
- Other schemes: occupancy fraud (intended use), straw buyer (real borrower), silent second (hidden down payment financing).
- Income discrepancy: resolve it with the borrower and submit verified income; never alter the application without her knowledge.
- SAR: never disclosed to the person involved; neither confirm nor deny (31 CFR 1029.320(d)).
Advertising and UDAAP
- Regulation N: no material misrepresentation about a term of a mortgage credit product, such as that no fees are charged; the advertiser is liable even if a vendor drafted the ad (12 CFR 1014.3).
- Triggering terms: downpayment, number of payments or period of repayment, amount of any payment, amount of any finance charge (12 CFR 1026.24(d)(1)); they require the downpayment, repayment terms over the full term and the APR (12 CFR 1026.24(d)(2)).
- Unfair: substantial injury not reasonably avoidable and not outweighed by benefits; intent is not an element (12 U.S.C. 5531(c)(1)).
Sample questions (5)
1. Under 12 CFR 1026.36(d)(1), compensation paid to a loan originator that is a fixed percentage of the amount of credit extended is:
- prohibited, because a percentage payment is a proxy for the interest rate.
- prohibited, because the loan amount is a term of the transaction.
- permitted, and it may be subject to a minimum or maximum dollar amount.
- permitted, and the percentage may increase in tiers as the loan amount rises.
Under § 1026.36(d)(1)(ii) of Regulation Z, the amount of credit extended is not a term of a transaction or a proxy for a term when the compensation is a fixed percentage of the amount of credit, and “such compensation may be subject to a minimum or maximum dollar amount”. So the payment is neither a prohibited proxy for the interest rate nor compensation based on a term of the transaction. Comment 36(d)(1)-9 to Regulation Z adds that the percentage must be fixed and must not vary with the amount of credit, so tiered percentages that rise with the loan amount are not allowed.
2. Under 12 CFR 1024.14(e), an agreement or understanding to refer settlement service business:
- is not covered by the rule unless it is written and signed by both parties.
- is allowed when the payment does not increase any charge to the borrower.
- requires proof that the referring person was paid in cash for each referral.
- may exist without a writing, based on a practice or pattern of conduct.
Section 1024.14(e) states that an agreement or understanding “need not be written or verbalized but may be established by a practice, pattern or course of conduct”, so no signed writing is required. The thing of value need not be cash, because § 1024.14(d) of Regulation X says that a payment “does not require transfer of money”, and § 1024.14(g)(2) of Regulation X makes the absence of any increase in a charge irrelevant.
3. Under 12 CFR 1024.14(d), the term thing of value in the anti-kickback rule is defined as:
- money paid in cash or by check directly to the person who made the referral.
- any benefit, such as monies, discounts, commissions, trips, or special-rate services.
- a payment whose value exceeds a dollar threshold that the Bureau sets each year.
- a payment that the recipient must report as income on a federal tax return.
Section 1024.14(d) defines the term broadly: it “includes, without limitation, monies, things, discounts, salaries, commissions, fees” and also trips and services at special or free rates, and “payment” does not require a transfer of money. The definition is not limited to cash, sets no dollar threshold, and does not depend on tax reporting.
4. Priya Nair, a loan originator at Summit Ridge Lending, receives $300 from Pinehaven Title LLC for each borrower she directs to Pinehaven, and she performs no title services. Under Section 8 of RESPA and Regulation X, this payment is:
- prohibited, because it is a fee for referring settlement service business.
- permitted, because the payer is a licensed title company in good standing.
- permitted, because the borrower's title charges do not increase as a result.
- not prohibited unless Priya and Pinehaven signed a written referral agreement.
Section 1024.14(b) provides that “No person shall give and no person shall accept any fee, kickback or other thing of value pursuant to any agreement or understanding” that settlement service business will be referred. An unchanged borrower charge is irrelevant under section 1024.14(g)(2), the payer's license does not matter, and no written agreement is needed under section 1024.14(e).
5. Cobalt Creek Bank holds a free educational seminar on mortgage programs for local real estate agents. Attendance is not conditioned on referring business to the bank, and the bank pays none of the agents' ordinary business expenses. Under Regulation X, the seminar is:
- a prohibited thing of value, because any free event for agents is banned.
- a normal promotional and educational activity that Section 8 permits.
- prohibited, because the agents are in a position to refer settlement services.
- permitted, but the bank must first report the seminar to the Bureau in writing.
Section 1024.14(g)(1)(vi) permits “Normal promotional and educational activities that are not conditioned on the referral of business” and that do not defray expenses otherwise incurred by those in a position to refer. Being a referral source does not make an event unlawful, and the rule has no Bureau reporting step.